Making College “Worth It” – Season 2, Episode 10

In this episode, Nolan and Jessie talk with Travis Maynard, Tim Peeples, and Paula Rosinski about their recent research on alumni perceptions of generative AI. Drs. Maynard, Peeples, and Rosinski share what they’re learning about the role of AI in professionals’ day-to-day lives, across professional, civic, and personal spaces. They also highlight what they’ve learned about “power users” of AI and suggest implications for teaching and practicing effective AI use in higher education.

View a transcript of this episode.

Meet our Guests

Headshot of Travis Maynard

Travis Maynard is an Assistant Professor of English at Elon University where he teaches courses in the Professional Writing and Rhetoric program. Dr. Maynard’s research interests include multimodal composition and alumni writing experiences. In the classroom he enjoys giving students the opportunity to be creative while developing their rhetorical thinking and technological skills. He finds joy in the consistently impressive work his students create. His work has recently appeared in Computers and Composition, Prompt: A Journal of Academic Writing Assignments, and Writing Beyond the University: Preparing Lifelong Learners for Lifewide Writing.

head shot of Tim Peeples

Tim Peeples is Senior Associate Provost Emeritus and Professor of Humanities at Elon University. He also holds the position of Senior Scholar in the Center for Engaged Learning. He is the author of the forthcoming book, The Mattering of Liberal Education: Isocrates, Rhetoric, and New Materialisms.

Paula Rosinski

Paula Rosinski is professor of Professional Writing & Rhetoric and director of Writing Across the University in the Center for Writing Excellence at Elon University where she co-coordinates the Disciplinary Writing Consultants program, co-chairs her institution’s AI Task Force, and previously led her institution’s Quality Enhancement Plan on Writing Excellence. Paula serves on the Association of Writing Across the Curriculum’s (AWAC) Executive Committee (previously as member-at-large and currently as treasurer) and her recent research focuses on WAC faculty AI professional development, alumni AI professional writing practices, and writing center consultant and client attitudes towards AI. Her recent publications include the co-edited collection, Writing Beyond the University: Preparing Lifelong Learners for Lifewide Writing (Center for Engaged Learning Open Access Book Series, 2022) and the co-authored chapter, “Understanding the Landscape of Generative AI Use among Writing Center Clients,” forthcoming in Writing Centers and AI: Generating Early Conversations (Eds. Elisabeth Buck and Joshua Botvin, WAC Clearinghouse Perspectives on Writing).

Episode Credits

This episode is co-hosted by Jessie L. Moore, Director of Elon University’s Center for Engaged Learning, and Nolan Schultheis, a second-year student at Elon University, studying Psychology with an interest in law. Jessie L. Moore also edited the episode. Making College “Worth It” is produced by Elon University’s Center for Engaged Learning.

Episode art was created by Nolan Schultheis and Jennie Goforth.

Funky Percussions is by Denys Kyshchuk (@audiocoffeemusic) - https://www.audiocoffee.net/. Soft Beat is by ComaStudio.  

Generative AI Tools Mentioned in the Episode

Explore Center Resources Related to this Episode

Book cover for Writing Beyond the University: Preparing Lifelong Learners for Lifewide Writing. Edited by Julia Bleakney, Jessie L. Moore, and Paula Rosinski.

Writing Beyond the University

Glowing blue pen hovering above notebook. White quote text: "As educators, we need to be re-examining the borders between “learn” and “do” and how we might scaffold both in the age of generative AI.”

Blue Books and In-Class Writing Are Not a Panacea 

In comments sections and replies in both educator spaces and mass media articles, it’s common to see exhortations to simply return to an earlier time where students demonstrated knowledge in class. I myself recall needing to remember to stop by…

Orange brain with AI network and quote text: "...preliminary data suggested that initially relying on LLM help early on affected later performance, even if the LLM use stopped for the later task. That’s a powerful finding.”

When it Comes to AI in Education, Timing May Matter 

I’ve participated in several professional education opportunities this summer related to AI as a tool for higher education, and one of my biggest takeaways is that there is little agreement among faculty.   Even in a tiny academic unit of fewer…

Student using iPad with white text: "GenAI is a continuing evolution of inquiry and writing technologies, not something that’s entirely new.”

GenAI and the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning

Each summer, the Center for Engaged Learning facilitates week-long meetings for three distinct international, multi-institutional, and multidisciplinary research seminars that foster collaborative scholarship of teaching and learning (SoTL) on focused engaged learning topics. During this summer’s research seminar meetings, generative…

This flaw in simulations can create misrepresent cultural dynamics, portraying groups based on leaked bias instead of reality.” with young woman and older German man talking through cup phone.

AI and Learning About Cultures 

  Several of the high-impact practices in higher education require learners to practice stepping out of their cultural comfort zone. For instance, a co-op or internship can require adapting to the culture of a workplace. Undergraduate research means learning to…

AI-generated image of professor handing student paper to a robot to grade. Quote: "If AI is of limited value in detecting AI, does it have value on its own in assessing or providing feedback on student writing? "

Should AI be Involved in Assessing Student Work? 

I was at a campus workshop this week, and we discussed this recent article about a student requesting a tuition refund after discovering a piece of course content was generated by ChatGPT (Hill 2025). I thought the use of the…

"Both students and teachers should reflect on what happened when they used AI. Did the tool work like they expected? Did you find bias or other problems?" -Amanda Sturgill

How Might Generative AI Impact DEI in University Classes  

I sometimes describe the content that generative AI creates as pumpkin spice latte content, to get a giggle from my students. I think the analogy holds up: It’s tasty. It’s filling. And it is absolutely not anything that will surprise…